Finde Sugar Island Hotels

„The property was extremely well kept and a very welcoming staff.“

„All good“

„Beautiful property in a prime location walking distance to everything in Put in Bay. Very comfortable room (Beach Glass room) Great breakfast. Would definitely stay here again. 10/10.“

„Staff was amazing “

„Great location! Super friendly staff. Great accommodations!“

„Rooms were very clean and pleasant ,location was perfect less than a 5 minute walk from downtown,very peaceful and the staff was very helpful kind.“

„The manager Dawn was amazing and very helpful with accommodating us. This was our first time at Putin Bay, and we will be back and staying at this lodge. The whole staff was very kind. The bartender was amazing. I love the whole set up. When we got there, our Golf cart was there and we got to use that. And Dawn put our stuff in the conference room until her room was ready. So we got to enjoy the day. What a blessing our stay was. Thank you.“

„Front desk staff not welcoming“

„The staff was friendly and helpful. The room could use some updates. Water pressure was superb, but the curtain kept clinging to me. Very aggravating. Also, the in room coffee was terrible. The packaged creamer was crunchy. The room was sufficient for a 2 night stay and in a great location, but probably would not stay there again. A large group of young people were congregated directly outside of our window on the second night around 2:45 am. Our room was along an alley. I understand full well ...

„Clean rooms. Fun pool. Staff was very nice. Multiple bars were fun“

„The room is fine. I did not like having to park my vehicle, offsite and walking even further to another hotel and go to their office to check into my hotel.“

„Good experience“

„Every room is a suite, but prices vary, and the staff is young. They need a checklist to make sure each room has what they need (shampoo, cups, A/C on…) It’s Pretty around the pool and hot tub was big. I like the mile walk to town in the morning when it’s quiet and calm next to the lake. The entire island is relaxing with great restaurants, yummy perch and walleye bites at the Village Pump. I would return in a minute. Looking forward to going again.“

„Staff very helpful“

„breakfast was a joke and not al all appropriate.“